Inevitably with the budget now past thoughts within hospitality are turning to what happens next, in particular with regard to the key campaign call advocated for by the industry this financial cycle: a sector-wide VAT cut.
While the team behind #VATsTheProblem begins plotting out its strategy for the year ahead, a lesser-known campaign group has come out swinging with a radical proposal to try and force the government’s hand.
Hospitality Voices, which is led by pub operator Andy Lennox, is calling on its members and supporters to ban MPs who have not publicly backed a VAT cut for the hospitality sector from their venues.
Set to come into force from 1 March 2027, the action is part of what the group describes as its ‘emergency agenda’ for the sector.
The proposed ban will draw on data from Hospitality Voices’ MP map, which splits politicians between those who have and haven’t recorded support for a sector VAT cut.
Those who have are considered ‘in’ and represented on the map in dark green. Everyone without confirmed VAT-cut support is labelled ‘out’ and shown in red.
The ban would apply to all those listed as ‘out’, which at the time of writing encompasses 317 MPs – a little under half of the 650 that sit in the House of Commons.
It follows a similar campaign that Lennox spearheaded in December last year, which saw operators protest against rising business rates and wider employment costs by banning Labour MPs.
The decision to target those who specifically haven’t backed a hospitality VAT cut doesn’t make it any more worthy. It simply shows binary thinking on subject that has much greater complexity
In contrast, this latest intervention will target politicians across all parties.
Speaking recently to The MA, Restaurant’s sister publication, Lennox justified the plans by saying there was ‘significant anger’ across the sector after Chancellor John Healey failed to announce a VAT cut for the sector in last month’s budget, despite Prime Minister Andy Burnham having previously voiced his support for one.
“The government needs to take us seriously and seemingly lobbying MPs and having the support for a VAT cut line with Europe of nearly 300 of them isn’t cutting through,” he said. “Further action is required.”
It’s a fair rationale, and Lennox’s activist-style approach is impressive; it speaks forcefully to the desperation businesses across the sector face right now. But the questions that linger are: can it really achieve anything, and does it have the potential to impede future progress?
Instinctively, I would put the answers as ‘no’ for the first question, and ‘yes’ for the second.
The group will doubtless point to its previous campaign against Labour MPs, which admittedly did help bring the sector’s frustrations into the national spotlight. But there is a difference between protesting against a government’s actions and seeking to exclude individual politicians who have not endorsed a particular policy.
What’s curious is that the group itself seems to recognise the importance of conventional political engagement.
Other campaigns being promoted by Hospitality Voices include one which encourages engagement between operators and their local representatives. Promoting a hostile action that drives a wedge between them seems more than a little counterproductive.
Moreso, however, the whole campaign smacks of pettiness. Frankly, it’s not a good look, and feels destined to push MPs away a time when an increasing number seem keen to listen to and engage with the sector’s call.
The decision to target those who specifically haven’t backed a hospitality VAT cut doesn’t make it any more worthy. It simply shows binary thinking on subject that has much greater complexity.
Being unwilling to publicly back a VAT cut is not necessarily the same as being opposed to one. MPs may have legitimate questions about the economics, the cost to the public purse or how such a measure should be funded. Treating all those who haven’t declared their support as opponents risks overlooking the nuance of the debate.
Ahead of the proposed ban, Hospitality Voices will be making a final push to secure a vote in parliament via a private member’s bill, which will call for an emergency VAT cut and a targeted 13% rate for small and medium-sized hospitality businesses to give operators ‘more room to protect jobs, invest in their businesses and keep serving their communities’.
The group is also calling for a TV debate on BBC Question Time to highlight the crisis facing the industry.
In contrast to its campaign plans, both those initiatives demonstrate an understanding that the real chance to secure lasting financial relief for the sector lies instead in having a continued open dialogue between the industry and Westminster.
As one senior figure from within the #VATsTheProblem campaign explained it to me last week: “We used to have a government that wasn’t willing to listen, now we have one that is but doesn’t have any money. Now we need to keep engaging and promoting our message, so that when there is some fiscal headroom that funding comes to us.”
Banning MPs will not help the sector’s VAT cut campaign. If anything, it has the potential to set it back.

