Government confirms transition period for strengthened tipping law

New code: Pub operators urged to review tipping policies
Under the rules set out in the draft revised code, employers will now be required to hold formal consultations whenever a new tipping policy or rule is introduced or materially changed. (Getty Images)

The government has confirmed there will be a transition period around the implementation of strengthened tipping legislation.

Changes to the statutory tipping law, which include the new requirement for employers to hold formal consultations whenever a new tipping policy is introduced, are scheduled to take effect on 1 January.

However, the draft revised code of practice on the fair and transparent distribution of tips, published this week, confirms that operators do not need to apply the new code until the next review of their tipping policy after 1 January 2027, which must be no later than three years from the date their current policy commenced.

Peter Davies, client services partner at WMT Troncmaster Services, has welcomed the announcement of a transitional implementation period, saying it will help support operators and ensure they’re not distracted over the busy festive season.

Commenting on the draft revised code more broadly, he said it sets a general standard that all operators must adhere to but continues to leave operators room, together with their teams, to interpret those principles in a way that works best for workers and does not set a ’one size fits all’.

“I’m pleased to see the new code of practice continues to recognise that hospitality operators come in many shapes and sizes and so do their tipping policies.”

Under the rules set out in the draft revised code, employers will now be required to hold formal consultations whenever a new tipping policy or rule is introduced or materially changed.

Alternatively, there must be a formal review at least once every three years.

It marks the most significant change to the Employment (Allocation of Tips) Act since it came into force in October 2024.

Currently, employers are encouraged, not obligated, to consult with staff on their tipping practices.

Consultations must be ’genuine’ and seek the views of all workers at each place of business where tips and service charges are generated.

If trade unions are recognised in the workplace consultation must be via union representatives.

Workers must be provided with a written summary of the (anonymised) views and comments raised in the consultation and a response from business or troncmaster.

Failure to hold consultations in line with the legislation will be enforced via employment tribunals.

Other updates to the draft revised code include greater clarity on the scope of who should and shouldn’t receive tips with an increased focus on the actual role a worker has.

For example, the new code does not prohibit the distribution of tips to central or head office workers, but places much more emphasis on what a worker does, rather than where they do it.

It states that workers who ‘directly interact’ with customers, such as reservations or sales staff, will likely qualify, as will those involved in the preparation of food, including chefs based in central production kitchens, and holding roles directly affecting the hospitality or guest experience at site regardless of whether they are personally based there.

Workers in roles with no interaction with customers and no impact on the service, food, experience or hospitality will likely not qualify.

Davies said: “On the question of central or offsite staff we welcome the new code’s increased focus on the actual role a worker has, the level of any interaction with customers, and how their role is involved with the service, food and drink, experience and hospitality that a customer paying a tip receives.

“We have always believed this to be a fairer test than a simple question of where a person is based, but again operators need to be able to justify and demonstrate why what they do and the decisions they take are fair.”

Elsewhere, Davies noted that contrary to advance speculation, the draft revised code does not ban or prohibit the distribution of a fixed or minimum sum of tips to a named person or role in advance, but says that operators should ’exercise caution’.

The code states fixed or set amounts awarded to some staff could have the effect of unfairly reducing the awards to other staff, particularly in periods of quieter trading and reminds operators that all awards should always be set by reference to available funds, job role and position, seniority or similar.

Davies commented that where all workers receive an appropriate minimum it will be easier to demonstrate fairness, and where only some workers receive fixed awards the business and tronc master would need to be able to show if challenged why this is fair given the facts.

“As with all awards, care should be taken to ensure that awards are reasonable, proportionate and based on facts and do not inadvertently or unfairly disadvantage one group of workers over another, and that tipping arrangements are open and have the broad agreement of the team,” Davies said.

James Brown, CEO of Brava Hospitality Group and the co-founder of cashless tipping platform TiPJAR, also singled out the importance of this update to the code.

In a statement, he said the comments on exercising caution around fixed or guaranteed awards paid out of the tronc is emblematic of where the government stands on the issue.

“Tribunals have to take the code into account,” he said.

“Calling it a ‘fixed award’ instead of a ‘guarantee’ won’t change the outcome. What counts is who carries the risk when tips fall.

“If I were a business owner or director weighing this paragraph against my business, my reputation and how a tribunal judge would read it, I personally wouldn’t go near this practice.”

He added that Brava recently acquired a business that has historically used fixed / guaranteed amounts and he was waiting for this guidance to decide on next steps.

“For me it now is unequivocal that we can no longer stand behind this practice and will need to transition away from it in time for the new code coming into force in January,” he added.

Following the publication of the draft revised code, the government has now said there will be no further legal changes to tipping legislation until at least 2029.

Davies added: “I also welcome the confirmation that there will be no further legislative change on tipping for the foreseeable future which will give operators and workers stability and certainty, and given the short period of time before the new code comes into effect the announcement of a transition period will help hard-pressed operators, particularly as we enter the busiest trading period of the year.”

To access the full draft revised code of practice on the fair and transparent distribution of tips, click here.