What the Milburn review could mean for hospitality

Happy redhead waitress serving customers in a restaurant and bringing food at their table.
Alan Milburn’s review singles out hospitality and retail, which together account for 37% of jobs held by 16–24-year-olds (Drazen - stock.adobe.com)

The former Labour health secretary’s independent review of youth employment calls for lower employer National Insurance costs and bigger hiring grants to help hospitality businesses take on more young workers.

A year in the making, Alan Milburn’s independent review of youth employment singles out hospitality and retail, which together account for 37% of jobs held by 16–24-year-olds. Published today (17 November), its headline recommendation for the two sectors is to raise the threshold at which employers start paying National Insurance for 21–24-year-olds from £5,000 to £10,000.

Milburn proposes phasing in the increase over five years, starting with hospitality and retail, subject to the state of the public finances.

Alongside the tax cut, he proposes extending the £3,000 Youth Jobs Grant to employers who hire a 16–24-year-old who has spent six months out of education, employment or training, regardless of whether they claim benefits. Businesses with fewer than 50 employees would receive an extra £2,000, with a further £2,000 available if the recruit faces substantial barriers to work.

The cost of hiring also came up in discussions with small hospitality employers, who told Milburn that the narrowing gap between youth and adult minimum wage rates makes them less inclined to take on inexperienced workers.

The minimum wage for 18–20-year-olds is currently £10.85 an hour, around 15% below the £12.71 National Living Wage for workers aged 21 and over, while the rate for 16–17-year-olds is £8.

Milburn recommends that the Low Pay Commission continue to weigh the pace of bringing the 18–20 rate into line with the National Living Wage against the potential impact on youth employment.

“They point in particular to the compression of the pay gap between younger and older workers,” Milburn writes. “Although the impact is heavily contested, if the cost of hiring an 18 year-old moves closer to the cost of hiring an older worker with several years’ experience, some employers will choose the safer option.”

Hospitality and retail employers also raised concerns about guaranteed hours under the Employment Rights Act, prompting Milburn to recommend that ministers make youth employment a primary consideration when implementing the rules and limit any adverse effects on seasonal and temporary work.

The review also asks ministers to explore whether employers in sectors with large entry-level workforces should have to show they have made serious efforts to recruit young people before they can access work visas.

Milburn says any such measure should be tested against the risk of labour shortages.

The review sets out a 10-year programme aimed at helping nearly one million young people who are currently out of education, employment or training.

“This report sets out a new ambition for the country: a generational promise that every young person will be guaranteed the opportunity to earn or learn,” Milburn says.

Matthew Summerbell, delivery director for hospitality at apprenticeship provider Lifetime Training, welcomes the proposed National Insurance cut and says employers also need support to keep young recruits in work.

“Government should consider whether the more generous approach already applied to under-21s could provide a better model,” he says.

“If the ambition is to significantly increase youth employment, a stronger incentive could give employers greater confidence to create opportunities at scale.”

“Employers need the capacity to provide the training, mentoring and ongoing development that helps someone succeed and stay in employment.”